Skip to content

Commit 9c2e9c7

Browse files
committed
Incorporate suggestion from Nicoleta.
1 parent 01a883c commit 9c2e9c7

File tree

1 file changed

+25
-20
lines changed

1 file changed

+25
-20
lines changed

sections/02-use-cases.qmd

Lines changed: 25 additions & 20 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -123,25 +123,30 @@ wide range of stakeholders and tap a broad base of expertise.
123123
## Community science
124124

125125
Another interesting use case for open-source standards is community/citizen
126-
science. This approach, which has grown in the last 20 years, has many benefits
127-
for both the research field that harnesses the energy of non-scientist members
128-
of the community to engage with scientific data, as well as to the community
129-
members themselves who can draw both knowledge and pride in their participation
130-
in the scientific endeavor. It is also recognized that unique broader benefits
131-
are accrued from this mode of scientific research, through the inclusion of
132-
perspectives and data that would not otherwise be included. To make data
133-
accessible to community scientists, and to make the data collected by community
134-
scientists accessible to professional scientists, it needs to be provided in a
135-
manner that can be created and accessed without specialized instruments or
136-
specialized knowledge. Here, standards are needed to facilitate interactions
137-
between an in-group of expert researchers who generate and curate data and a
138-
broader set of out-group enthusiasts who would like to make meaningful
139-
contributions to the science. This creates a particularly stringent constraint
140-
on transparency and simplicity of standards. Creating these standards in a
141-
manner that addresses these unique constraints can benefit from OSS tools, with
142-
the caveat that some of these tools require additional expertise. For example,
143-
if the standard is developed using git/GitHub for versioning, this would
144-
require learning the complex and obscure technical aspects of these system that
145-
are far from easy to adopt, even for many professional scientists.
126+
science. An early example of this approach is OpenStreetMap
127+
(https://www.openstreetmap.org), which allows users to contribute to the
128+
project development with code and data and freely use the maps and other
129+
related geospatial datasets. But this example is not unique. Overall, this
130+
approach has grown in the last 20 years and has been adopted in many different
131+
fields. It has many benefits for both the research field that harnesses the
132+
energy of non-scientist members of the community to engage with scientific
133+
data, as well as to the community members themselves who can draw both
134+
knowledge and pride in their participation in the scientific endeavor. It is
135+
also recognized that unique broader benefits are accrued from this mode of
136+
scientific research, through the inclusion of perspectives and data that would
137+
not otherwise be included. To make data accessible to community scientists, and
138+
to make the data collected by community scientists accessible to professional
139+
scientists, it needs to be provided in a manner that can be created and
140+
accessed without specialized instruments or specialized knowledge. Here,
141+
standards are needed to facilitate interactions between an in-group of expert
142+
researchers who generate and curate data and a broader set of out-group
143+
enthusiasts who would like to make meaningful contributions to the science.
144+
This creates a particularly stringent constraint on transparency and simplicity
145+
of standards. Creating these standards in a manner that addresses these unique
146+
constraints can benefit from OSS tools, with the caveat that some of these
147+
tools require additional expertise. For example, if the standard is developed
148+
using git/GitHub for versioning, this would require learning the complex and
149+
obscure technical aspects of these system that are far from easy to adopt, even
150+
for many professional scientists.
146151

147152

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)